Roof Leak Repair in West Islip, NY
Water stains beside the fireplace or on the wall under the chimney are a very common sign of a roof leak in West Islip homes. We find out whether it’s the flashing, the chimney or the roof around it.
Roof leak repair in West Islip
When the leak is next to the chimney
West Islip is just east of Babylon village, in the Town of Islip, and it’s a short drive from our shop. Plenty of houses here have a brick chimney running up through the roof, and that chimney is one of the most common places for a roof to leak.
The reason is simple. A chimney is a big, solid box sticking through a roof that moves a little with the seasons. The joint between brick and shingles is sealed with metal flashing, and over the years that flashing loosens, rusts or gets covered in tar by someone trying a quick fix. Water then runs down the brick and into the attic or the wall beside the fireplace.
Scott Sasso, who started Advanced Roofing Siding and Gutters in 1993, comes out himself. He’ll check the flashing, the chimney cap and the bricks above the roof, tell you plainly which one is letting the water in and give you a free estimate.

30+Years fixing Long Island leaks
Signs of a chimney leak
How chimney leaks show up indoors
If you see any of these near the chimney, it’s worth getting it checked before the wood around it takes on more water.
- Stains on the ceiling beside the chimney. The most common sign. The stain often sits right where the chimney passes through the ceiling.
- Damp or peeling paint on the fireplace wall. Water running down the brick inside the wall pushes paint and plaster off.
- Wet framing around the chimney in the attic. Darkened wood and damp insulation where the chimney passes through the attic.
- Tar smeared around the base. From the roof or with binoculars, globs of black tar usually mean the flashing failed and was patched.
- Loose or missing metal at the brick. The counterflashing set into the mortar can pull out, leaving a gap at the top of the flashing.
- Cracked chimney crown. The cement cap on top of the chimney can crack and let water down inside the masonry. That one isn’t flashing at all.

How we fix it
Sealing the chimney joint properly
A proper chimney leak repair in West Islip usually involves these steps.
- Find the real source. Scott checks the flashing, the bricks above the roof and the crown, then the attic below.
- Remove the old patchwork. Old tar and tired metal come off so the joint can be rebuilt properly.
- New step flashing. Pieces of flashing are woven in with each course of shingles up the sides of the chimney.
- New counterflashing. Metal is set into the mortar joints and lapped over the step flashing so water can’t get behind it.
- Back and front pieces. The uphill side gets proper protection so water is steered around the chimney instead of pooling against it.
If the bricks, mortar or crown need masonry work, Scott will tell you, so you’re not paying for flashing that won’t solve it. See our chimney flashing repair page for more.
How it works
Our Process
1
Contact us and schedule an inspection.
Phone 516-987-7478 or send the form. Mention it’s near the chimney. You’ll hear back within 24 hours.
2
We evaluate and repair or replace your roof.
Scott checks the chimney and flashing, explains the cause and the crew rebuilds the joint.
3
Rest easy knowing your house and family are protected.
No more stains by the fireplace, and the roof around the chimney sealed up.
Why West Islip homeowners call us
We find the actual cause
A lot of chimney leaks have been patched before. We’d rather fix it once, properly.
Close to West Islip
Our shop is in West Babylon, just the other side of Babylon village.
Flashing done the proper way
Step and counterflashing, not another layer of tar.
Honest if it’s the masonry
If the chimney itself is the problem, we’ll tell you.
Owner inspects the leak
Scott checks the chimney and attic himself.
Fully Licensed & Insured
Proper cover on every repair.
BBB A+, family owned
Running the same way since 1993.
Free chimney leak estimate
Leak by the chimney in West Islip?
Fill in the form with your address and where the stain is. Photos of the chimney from the yard and the stain inside help a lot. Scott will arrange a time to come out.
- Free estimate
- Reply within 24 hours
- Flashing, crown and bricks all checked
- Photos welcome
Request a leak repair estimate
West Islip · Free estimate · Since 1993
Real Google reviews
Homeowners on Scott and his crew
Scott and his crew were great. After the job was started, it was discovered that more replacement work was needed. They were honest, respectful of the property and fixed ALL the problems by 5pm same day. I would recommend Advanced Roofing to everyone.
Professionalism, Quality and Efficiency are the words I would use to describe working with Scott and Advanced Roofing and Gutters. This was honestly a seamless experiences. First, Scott is incredibly professional and responsive, he called me back immediately after requesting a quote. The quote given for the services was transparent and throughout the job Scott was highly communicative as it progressed. Scotts crew arrived early and on time, they ripped and replaced the roof in one day and replaced the gutters the next. If you need a roof done, you will not be disappointed in your experience with Scott and his crew.
We recently had our roof and gutters replaced, and the entire experience was excellent from start to finish. Scott the owner and his team were professional, punctual, and clearly took pride in their work. Scott explained the process thoroughly and kept us informed every step of the way. His crew worked efficiently and completed the job on time, while also making sure everything was cleaned up properly afterward no nails or debris left behind. I would highly recommend Advanced Roofing to anyone who is looking for an honest, trustworthy company whose work speaks for itself.
Is my chimney leak a roofing problem or a masonry problem?
It can be either. If the flashing has failed, it’s roofing work. If the crown is cracked or the bricks and mortar are soaking up water, it’s masonry. Scott checks both and tells you which.
Someone already tarred around my chimney. Why is it still leaking?
Tar cracks as it ages and the roof moves. It also hides what’s underneath. A lasting fix usually means removing it and putting in new flashing.
We never use the fireplace. Does that matter?
Not for the leak. The chimney still sits in the roof and still needs to be flashed properly, whether you use it or not.
Will the repair look patched?
We match the shingles around the chimney as closely as we can. On an older roof, new shingles may look a little brighter at first.
Should I replace the roof instead?
If the rest of the roof is in good shape, no. The chimney can be reflashed on its own. If the roof is worn out, it often makes sense to do both together, and Scott will tell you honestly.
More in West Islip
Related services and nearby towns
Other services in West Islip
- Chimney Flashing RepairLearn more →
- Roof Flashing RepairLearn more →
- Roof RepairIn West Islip →
- Roof Decking RepairLearn more →
- Roof InspectionsLearn more →
- Roof ReplacementIn West Islip →
Leak repair in nearby towns
- Babylon, NYRoof Leak Repair in Babylon
- North Babylon, NYRoof Leak Repair in North Babylon
- Bay Shore, NYRoof Leak Repair in Bay Shore
- Brightwaters, NYRoof Leak Repair in Brightwaters
Go back to roofing in West Islip, read about roof leak repair, or see every town we serve.
