Roof Replacement in Sayville, NY
What’s under your old shingles decides how long your new roof lasts. On a Sayville replacement, we strip every layer, fix the wood underneath and build the new roof up from a solid deck.
Roof replacement in Sayville
A new roof is only as good as what’s under it
Sayville is on the South Shore, east of Oakdale, and many of its homes have been around long enough to be on their second or even third roof. Sometimes a past roofer laid new shingles straight over the old ones to save a day. It looks fine from the street, but nobody has seen the wood underneath in a long time.
When we replace a roof in Sayville, every layer comes off. That’s the only way to see the decking, the old flashing and any damage left behind by leaks that were never quite fixed. Scott Sasso, the owner, checks the bare roof himself, so problems are found and dealt with before anything new goes on.
It’s the part of the job you’ll never see once it’s finished. It’s also the part that makes the biggest difference to how the new roof holds up.

30+Years re-roofing Long Island
What we often find
Under the shingles of an older roof
You can’t see these from the yard, but they show up again and again once an old roof is stripped back.
- Extra layers. Two or three layers of old shingles stacked up. One of our Google reviewers mentions the crew removing three layers of old roofing from their house.
- Soft plywood near the eaves. Years of overflowing gutters or ice backing up at the edge leave the bottom few feet of decking soft. We replace that plywood.
- Dark stains around the chimney. Old leaks at the chimney often leave stained or weakened wood that a quick patch on top never reached.
- Old flashing reused. When a roof was laid over, the old flashing was often left in place and tarred. We put in new flashing on a replacement.
- Gaps or old board decking. Some older houses have boards instead of plywood underneath. Scott checks whether it’s solid enough to roof over or needs sheathing.
- Blocked or missing vents. Attic vents covered up by earlier roofs, or never put in at all. That traps heat and moisture and shortens a roof’s life.

How we rebuild it
From bare wood to a finished roof
This is the order of work on a typical Sayville roof replacement.
- Prepare the site. Dump truck in the driveway, tarps over shrubs and walkways.
- Strip every layer. All the old shingles and underlayment come off, right down to the deck.
- Repair the deck. Scott walks the bare roof. Bad plywood or boards are replaced and you’re told what was found.
- Weatherproof it. New underlayment, new drip edge and new flashing at walls, chimneys, valleys and pipes.
- Shingle and vent. New shingles from the eaves up, with ventilation set up so the attic can breathe.
- Clean the site. Everything is hauled away and the yard is swept with a magnet for stray nails.
Scott will give you an idea of the timing when he quotes, because it depends on the size of the roof and how many layers are on it.
Start to finish
Our Process
1
Contact us and schedule an inspection.
Call 516-987-7478 or send us the form, and you’ll hear back within 24 hours to book a free estimate.
2
We evaluate and repair or replace your roof.
Scott checks the roof from the top down, explains the job and then oversees the tear-off and re-roof.
3
Rest easy knowing your house and family are protected.
A new roof on a solid deck, with the old one gone and your yard left tidy.
Why Sayville homeowners choose us
We don’t cover up what we find
The cheapest way to put on a new roof is to skip the parts nobody sees. We don’t work that way.
Full tear-offs
Every old layer comes off. We don’t shingle over a roof.
The owner checks the bare deck
Scott looks at the wood himself before a single new shingle goes on.
You hear about surprises first
If something unexpected turns up under the old roof, you’ll know about it before it’s fixed.
Tidy, careful crews
Gardens, patios and driveways are protected, and we leave the place clean.
Fully Licensed & Insured
On every replacement, large or small.
Since 1993
Family owned, BBB Accredited and rated A+.
Get a free estimate
Is your Sayville roof due for replacing?
Send us the address and anything you know about the roof: how old it is, whether it’s been laid over, where it’s leaked. Scott will come and look.
- Free replacement estimate
- A reply within 24 hours
- Full tear-off on every new roof
- Owner checks the decking
Book a free roof estimate
Sayville · Since 1993 · Free estimate
Real Google reviews
From homeowners who replaced their roofs
Extremely happy with the work we had done by Advanced Roofing. We had Scott and his crew replace the roof with full plywood replacement and new gutter installation. We couldn’t be more pleased with how everything turned out. The crew worked quickly and were respectful of the property. Scott’s communication during the entire process was excellent and we would definitely recommend Advanced Roofing for your next project.
Scott's large crew was experienced, thorough, and efficient. They adeptly removed three layers of old roofing and expertly installed our new roof in a single day. Scott was directly involved in overseeing progress and remained on site afterwards to survey all details and ensure a full cleanup. All our questions were answered before and after the work was completed. We feel confident in recommending this company. Scott and his workers take their job seriously, gave us personal attention, and delivered results that resulted in both good value and high quality.
Scott the owner of Advanced Roofing & Siding came highly recommended from a client of mine. From the initial phone conversation to the estimate and hiring, Scott was an absolute professional! He was punctual, detailed with the process, gave honest advice and feedback with my questions and his pricing was fair. He brought the samples to my house and I was able to pick them out on the spot not having to run around, saving me time as well! He just finished the job and I could not be happier! Scott and his team were efficient, unbelievable craftsmanship and so clean! At the end of each day they left my house immaculate and organized. His team was so nice as well. They all pay attention to the smallest details, which means so much. Scott and his team achieved my vision and I could not be happier! I did a full roof replacement (had 3 layers btw), new board and batten siding and new gutters. If you are looking for any roof or siding needs, call Scott at Advanced Roofing & Siding, hands down the best! Thank you Scott and your team, I am grateful!
Roof replacement in Sayville
Good questions to ask
Have a different question? Ring us on 516-987-7478.
How do I know if my roof has more than one layer?
Sometimes you can see it at the roof edge, where the shingle ends look thick. Scott checks this when he inspects, and it’s one of the things he’ll tell you about in the estimate.
Why not just put new shingles over the old ones?
Laying over hides the deck, keeps old flashing in place and adds weight. Stripping the roof lets us find and fix problems while the roof is open.
Is it noisy?
Yes, tear-off day is loud, especially inside the house. Some people prefer to be out for part of the day. Pets are often happier somewhere quieter too.
Where does the dump truck go?
Usually in the driveway, so the crew can throw the old roof straight into it. Scott will talk it through with you so you know where to park.
Will there be nails in my lawn afterwards?
We go to a lot of trouble to prevent it. Tarps catch most debris, and the crew runs a magnet over the lawn, beds and driveway before leaving.
More in Sayville
Related services and nearby towns
Other services in Sayville
- Roof Plywood ReplacementLearn more →
- Roof Decking RepairLearn more →
- Roof Ventilation UpgradesLearn more →
- Asphalt Shingle ReplacementLearn more →
- Chimney Flashing RepairLearn more →
- GuttersLearn more →
Roof replacement close to Sayville
Go back to roofing in Sayville, read the roof replacement overview, or see all areas we serve.
